Who, What or Where Am I? (A Middle-Earth Game)

[The Good Hunter]

Good glob Aik, you really have us stumped!

Are you the Ring Verse?

[Aikári Salmarinian]

Frost: You'll get there in time, I am sure. Just getting on the right track.

42. Azh nagh.. Sorry, but not the Ring Inscription.

[Rivvy Elf]

Is this thing directly referenced in The Lord of the rings?

[Aikári Salmarinian]

43. No, the legend is not directly referred to in the book of 'Lord of the Rings'. (Very good question!)

[Rivvy Elf]

Is this legend directly referred to in The Silmarillion?

[Aikári Salmarinian]

44. No, the legend is not directly referred to in the book of 'Silmarillion'. I am not really certain about this, as there is a section of Numenor in the book.

[The Good Hunter]

Are you related to the water?

[Aikári Salmarinian]

45. Yes, I have a relation of sorts with water.

[Drífa]

Are you the Guildhouse of the Venturers where all the records were kept, including all the accurate charts of Númenor?

[Aikári Salmarinian]

46. No, I am not the Guild of Adventurers.

[Drífa]

Is this legend found in, Unfinished Tales exclusively?

[Aikári Salmarinian]

47. To my knowledge, yes it is found in the Unfinished Tales only.

[The Good Hunter]

Are you the founding of Vinyalondë?

[Drífa]

Are you the diamond Aldarion gave Erendis, a gift he had brought back from his journeys to Middle-earth, that she wore on her brow, which later became a tradition?

[Rivvy Elf]

Can you literally be held in one hand?

[Aikári Salmarinian]

Recap:

1. I could have a sort of relation to the Eldar, but sadly to say I am not.
2. Aye I could be capitalised if you wish me to be.
3. No I am not metal.
4. Yes, it could be used a reliable weapon.
5. No, I am not utilised by the enemy, but I could be if they knew about me and then corrupt me.
6. Yes, that could happen, that some people might consider going to war in order to obtain me, to safeguard or destroy; depending how important they find me.
7. Yes, some Mannish people do certainly safekeep me.
8. Harm I don't know, but the Witchking would not like me at all.
9. In a sense yes, people use me in communication.
10. Alas I am not round at all or made of crystal.
11. No, I am not sharp.
12. And no, I am not the Red Arrow (was a nice guess though, with the symbolism behind the weapon you're heading bit in the direction!).
13. No, I did not exist in the First Age.
14. No, I am not Aragorn's standard blowing in the wind (nice guess though! I love the try for symbolism .)
15. I am entirely created for Men, but have a tiny connection the Elves.
16. I have something symbolic over me, but no, I haven't really a status, unless you're in awe of me.
17. Sorry no, I am not a crown.
18. No, I am not Hilifirien/Eilinaer, Elendil's tomb, but I have something in common with the era Elendil lived.
19. Yes, in essence I am a stationary object.
20. Yes, in essence I am easy imflammable.
21. Yes, in essence there is writing on the object.
22. No, I am not the Gondorian beacons.
23. No, I don't exist in the Third Age. (was waiting on that question )
24. Yes, I am connected to Númenor surely.
25. No, I am not a tree burned in sacrifice to Melkor.
26. No, I am not a ship. (Nice guess though, was forgotten about the Alcarondas )
27. No, I am not the Scroll of Kings. (You are getting close.)
28. No, I am not the letter of Gil-Galad, but I have the times in common Tar-Meneldur and Tar-Eldarion lived.
29. No and yes....lol. Both kings might have known about me or perhaps not, but considering my nature there is a likely possibility they knew me. (Stumped yes I believe. It is actually not that hard considering your choice, which was a clever one.)
30. No, I am certainly not the Guild of Venturers, but they could have known me.
31. Yes, I am certainly a script on paper for those who can read, but it is not my only form of existence.
32. I am not a city, nor a port.
33. Some font(s) in My Name are Capitalised. So I can be capitalised if you wish to write me down (the title in written form)
34. Sorry, I am not edible.
35. Sorry, I am not the legend "the Mariner's Wife". (But you're close now).
36. An abstract object/thing? eh... yes I guess so (not certain), considering my nature I don't think Men change me, because my nature changes then with it.
36a. Ah thanks! Yeah the object is definitely abstract then, of a creative nature.
37. Sorry, I have nothing to do with laws or successions.
38. No, I am not a royal object.
39. No, I am not a holiday.
40. Yes, I am a legend definitely.
41. No, I am not Bilbo's poem from the late Third Age.
42. Azh nagh.. Sorry, but not the Ring Inscription.
43. No, the legend is not directly referred to in the book of 'Lord of the Rings'. (Very good question!)
44. No, the legend is not directly referred to in the book of 'Silmarillion'. I am not really certain about this, as there is a section of Numenor in the book.
45. Yes, I have a relation of sorts with water.
46. No, I am not the Guild of Adventurers.
47. To my knowledge, yes it is found in the Unfinished Tales only.
48. No, I am not the founding of Vinyalondë.
49. No, I am not the diamond that Aldarion gave to Erendis.
50. Yes, as I am part of the Unfinished Tales book, I can definitely be held in one hand.
51. No, it is not mentioned in the chapter of Erendis and Aldarion. Neither it is the legend of Aldarion of Erendis which was already asked and answered under nr. 35.
52. Yes, it is mentioned in Part 2, SA.
53. No, but I could sing the song of Nimrodel (--> Aiks). Little joke, it is not. Nimrodel lived never on Numenor.
54. No, I am not the bough Numenorean women tie to leaving ships.
55. No, I am not a person.
56. No, the Axe, but the Downfall(en) are taken up in my text, but also people as Aldarion and Erendis..
57. Neither the Line of Elros, and the Witchking would use/plot my textual nature for evil purposes, if not Sauron intercepts him first.
58. Yes, I am the Description of the Island of Numenor.

Somewhat easier of What am I:
7. Yes, some Mannish people do certainly safekeep me.
15. I am entirely created for Men, but have a tiny connection to the Elves.
16. I have something symbolic over me, but no, I haven't really a status, unless you're in awe of me.
19. Yes, in essence I am a stationary object.
20. Yes, in essence I am easy imflammable.
21. Yes, in essence there is writing on the object.
24. Yes, I am connected to Númenor surely.
31. Yes, I am certainly a script on paper for those who can read, but it is not my only form of existence.
40. Yes, I am a legend definitely.
45. Yes, I have a relation of sorts with water.
50. Yes, as I am part of the Unfinished Tales book, I can definitely be held in one hand.

NB: I love the shots of examples of what the legend could be.

[Rivvy Elf]

Is this thing directly mentioned in the Chapter, "ALDARION AND ERENDIS: The Mariner's Wife" in the Unfinished Tales?

[Aikári Salmarinian]

51. No, it is not mentioned in the chapter of Erendis and Aldarion. Neither it is the legend of Aldarion of Erendis which was already asked and answered under nr. 35.

[Rivvy Elf]

Is it mentioned anywhere in "Part 2: The Second Age" of The Unfinished Tales?

[Aikári Salmarinian]

52. Yes, it is mentioned in Part 2, SA.

[The Good Hunter]

Are you the Song of Nimrodel?

[Aikári Salmarinian]

53. No, but I could sing the song of Nimrodel (--> Aiks). Little joke, it is not. Nimrodel lived never on Numenor.

[Rivvy Elf]

Are you… the bough that a numenorean woman is supposed to tie to a seafaring ship before it departs?

[Aikári Salmarinian]

54. No, I am not the bough Numenorean women tie to leaving ships.

[Drífa]

Are you Tar-Elendil who was also called Parmaitë ( which means"Book-in-Hand" in Quenya (from parma= "book" and -maitë= "handed"), who with his own hand made many books and legends of the lore gathered by his grandfather?

[Aikári Salmarinian]

55. No, I am not a person. I am sorry, for I really like your shot about Tar-Elendil and revealed a quality about him that I didn't know, Drifa.

As I feel this is taking quite long I am going to give a hint, that might set you guessers on the right track. I want to give the floor to someone else now. *g* So we can start afresh. Would that be a good idea?

Hint: There are three legends about Numenor named in the second part of the Unfinished Tales.

[The Good Hunter]

A hint! thank you Aik for having mercy on us

Are you related to the Axe of Tuor, legendary weapon and heirloom lost in the Downfall?

[Drífa]

I am still not sure why the Witch-king would not like me at all , but, am I The Line Of Elros: Kings Of Númenor?

[Aikári Salmarinian]

Frost: Sure!

56. No, not the Axe, but the Downfall(en) are taken up in my text, but also people as Aldarion and Erendis.
57. Neither the Line of Elros, and the Witchking would use/plot my textual nature for evil purposes, if not Sauron intercepts him first.

[Drífa]

Are you A Description of the Island of Númenor?

[Aikári Salmarinian]

58. Yes, I am the Description. The first legend of the three about Numenor in part 2 of the Unfinished Tales.

The floor is for you Drifa! And all others thanks for the participation and the joy. I am glad to be back to guess modus.

[Drífa]

Well, that was quite the ride! Thanks, Aiks!

Who am I?

[Aikári Salmarinian]

Hmm, are you alive in the First Age?

[Rivvy Elf]

Are you alive in the Third Age?

[The Good Hunter]

Are you the living personification of the Description of Númenor? (Very well done Aik, I feel a bit like Gandalf after the Moria riddle)

[Drífa]

1. No, I am not alive in the FA.
2. Yes, I am alive in the TA.
3. I am not the living personification of the Description of Númenor.

[Aikári Salmarinian]

Ehm, are you an animal alive in the third age?

Frost: I can imagine you felt that way a bit.

[Rivvy Elf]

Did you die of "natural causes"?

[The Good Hunter]

Are you a member of the nobility?

[Drífa]

1. No, I am not alive in the FA.
2. Yes, I am alive in the TA.
3. I am not the living personification of the Description of Númenor.
4. No, I am not an animal.
5. It is not stated in the text how I died.
6. In a sense, yes.

[Aikári Salmarinian]

Not an animal... Eh, are you an Ent?

[Drífa]

1. No, I am not alive in the FA.
2. Yes, I am alive in the TA.
3. I am not the living personification of the Description of Númenor.
4. No, I am not an animal.
5. It is not stated in the text how I died.
6. In a sense, yes.
7. No, I am not an Ent.

[Aikári Salmarinian]

Someone serving or aligned with Sauron?

[Rivvy Elf]

Are you alive during the War of the Ring?

[The Good Hunter]

Are you a dwarf?

[Drífa]

8. No, never was I aligned with Sauron.
9. Yes, I am alive during the War Of The Ring.
10, By gosh, yes, I am a dwarf.

[The Good Hunter]

Do you live in Erebor?

[Rivvy Elf]

Are you Dis?

[Aikári Salmarinian]

Are you one of the twelve dwarves from Thorin's Compagny?

[Drífa]

11. I am pretty sure I did not live in Erebor.
12. No, I am not Dis.
13. Yes, I was a member of the Co.