Who, What or Where Am I? (A Middle-Earth Game)

[Dwim]

Is/was this place home to a population of people?

[Lail]

Since we're on a new page, I'll review:

Where Am I?
Clue: Lost

Previous responses:
1. No - not mentioned in The Hobbit.
2. No - not a river.
3. Yes - this place is accessible in the Third Age.
4. No. This place can be found.

New ones:
5. Yes - it is west of Rivendell.
6. People did not live precisely at this specific location, but people dwelt nearby, so overall that is a no.

[Boromir88]

Is this a location the 4 hobbits pass through on their journey to Rivendell?

[Lail]

7. Nope, not passed by or through by the hobbits.

[Boromir88]

I should have asked if any member of the Fellowship passed through here on their journey to Rivendell. Ah well, I'm going to take a stab with my guess for this round...

is it Tharbad? Where Boromir lost his horse on his search for Rivendell.

[Merewyn]

Is it Annuminas?

[Dwim]

Was this place considered part of the realm of Arnor?

[Aerlinn]

Is this place on the coast or does it border the ocean?

[Lail]

It is not Tharbad.
It is not Annuminas.

8. I'm going to admit I struggled to find a definitive answer in the 3 texts for this game. From my research online, it appears at least part of this location was part of Arnor at some point in time.
9. Yes, this is a coastal location.

[Boromir88]

Is the clue referring to something/an item that was lost at this location and never found again?

[Elvheimdros]

Would this location be on or associated with the Gulf of Lune?

[Balfur]

Is it the Ice Bay of Forochel, in which the Palantiri of the North were lost?

[Rivvy Elf]

Is it forochel... oh someone beat me to it

[Lail]

Yes, it is the Ice Bay of Forochel where both the Palantiri and King Arvedui (& crew) were lost.

On to you @Balfur with an honorable mention for @Dwarrow Elf.

[Balfur]

Had the hunch for a bit, but with the hobbits not passing through I was quite certain. Anyway, it seems this task falls to me again. We've had who and where; let's go for what!

What am I?
Clue: death

[Rivvy Elf]

Is this a weapon?

[Merewyn]

Is this muffin related? Or, related to any sort of spongy, cake-like baked product?

[Aerlinn]

IS IT CURRY? Is it something made of metal?

[Dwim]

Is this thing mentioned in The Silmarillion?

[Balfur]

Well that escalated according to an appropriate pace...
1. No, it is not a weapon.
2. No, alas it is not muffin related. Not even related to any sort of spongy, cake-like baked products.
3. Yes, this object is made of metal. (It is not curry though)
4. Yes, this object is mentioned in the Silmarillion

[Dwim]

Is this object associated with evil?

[Lail]

Is it a type of armor (shield, helmet, etc.)?

[Túrin]

Could the object be considered a type of jewelry or decoration?

[Boromir88]

Did groups of people fight over (and die) for this object?

[Aduchil]

Was it made by an Elf?

[Balfur]

5. No, not associated with evil
6. Not a type of armour
7. Yes, could be considered a type of jewelry or decoration
8. Yes, groups of people did fight over (and died for) this object.
9. No, it was not made by an Elf.

[Dwim]

Is it the Nauglamír?

[Balfur]

You are correct, @Dwim! It is indeed the Necklace of the Dwarves.
You're up!

[Dwim]

Thanks Balfur!

I'm going to go with a place this time, so guess away.

Clue: storage
Where am I?

[Boromir88]

Is this a location in The Shire?

[Dwim]

1. Yes, it is a location in The Shire

[Merewyn]

Is it the Lockholes at Michel Delving?

[Elvheimdros]

Is this location in Hobbiton?

[Boromir88]

is it the Mathom-house at Michel Delving? Where hobbits put items they don't have much use for but don't want to throw away.

[Rivvy Elf]

Is it the Stomach Of Michel Delving?

[Lail]

Is it the Scary quarries where Sharkey & Co. stored their loot?

[Aerlinn]

Is it the locked drawer, smelling of mothballs, where Bilbo stored his old cloak and hood?

[Dwim]

Well, that's a lot of guesses. But the only correct guess is the Lockholes. They were previously used as storage-tunnels before becoming a prison.

I would have to say that could be a record! I'll have to tighten my clues up...

@Ta'leus Shieldsong, your turn

[Merewyn]

As soon as you said Shire @Dwim, my mind immediately went to Michel Delving. I was debating the Mathom-House vs. the Lockholes, but I went with my gut since the Lockholes were mostly storage before. Haha.

Alrighty folks, a new one for you! I really hope this one stumps people.

What am I?
Clue: Noldor

[Elvheimdros]

Was this object (or I suppose objects) produced by the end of the First Age?

[Merewyn]

Yes, @Elvheimdros it was.

[Boromir88]

@Dwim I didn't realize the hobbits had so many storage places.

Is this item a weapon?

[Rivvy Elf]

Are they Feanorien Lamps?

[Merewyn]

@Boromir88 is it not specifically a weapon, no.
@Dwarrow Elf it is not the Feanorian Lamps.

[Aerlinn]

Was this object made by Feanor?

[Merewyn]

@Aerlinn, It was not made by Feanor.

I will give y'all a hint and say it is a very niche object.

[Boromir88]

Was this object made by the Noldor?

[Merewyn]

Yes, @Boromir88 is was made by the Noldor, for the Noldor.

[Elvheimdros]

Was this object made in Middle Earth (meaning, not the Undying Lands)?

[Boromir88]

Did others, besides the Noldor, ever acquire and use this object?