Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Sat Dec 31, 2022 4:01 pm
I never thought I'd win! 
Alrighty then...
Who am I?
Alrighty then...Who am I?
Lord of the Rings Fanatics Plaza
https://www.lotrfanaticsplaza.com/forum/
Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
https://www.lotrfanaticsplaza.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=1048
Page 3 of 55
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Sat Dec 31, 2022 7:28 pm
Are you immortal?
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Sat Dec 31, 2022 8:49 pm
1. I am immortal.
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Sat Dec 31, 2022 11:15 pm
Are you one of the Valar?
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Sun Jan 01, 2023 3:20 am
1. I am immortal.
2. I am not one of the Valar.
2. I am not one of the Valar.
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Sun Jan 01, 2023 3:36 am
Are you one of the Maiar?
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Sun Jan 01, 2023 3:01 pm
1. I am immortal.
2. I am not one of the Valar.
3. I am not one of the Maiar.
2. I am not one of the Valar.
3. I am not one of the Maiar.
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Sun Jan 01, 2023 4:24 pm
Are you alive during the War Of The Ring?
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Sun Jan 01, 2023 5:48 pm
1. I am immortal.
2. I am not one of the Valar.
3. I am not one of the Maiar.
4. I was not alive during the War of the Ring.
2. I am not one of the Valar.
3. I am not one of the Maiar.
4. I was not alive during the War of the Ring.
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Sun Jan 01, 2023 7:08 pm
Are you an elf then?
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Sun Jan 01, 2023 7:45 pm
1. I am immortal.
2. I am not one of the Valar.
3. I am not one of the Maiar.
4. I was not alive during the War of the Ring.
5. I am an elf.
2. I am not one of the Valar.
3. I am not one of the Maiar.
4. I was not alive during the War of the Ring.
5. I am an elf.
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Sun Jan 01, 2023 8:02 pm
Are you one of the Noldor?
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Mon Jan 02, 2023 12:46 am
1. I am immortal.
2. I am not one of the Valar.
3. I am not one of the Maiar.
4. I was not alive during the War of the Ring.
5. I am an elf.
6. I am one of the Noldor.
2. I am not one of the Valar.
3. I am not one of the Maiar.
4. I was not alive during the War of the Ring.
5. I am an elf.
6. I am one of the Noldor.
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Mon Jan 02, 2023 2:16 am
Are you female?
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Mon Jan 02, 2023 2:28 am
1. I am immortal.
2. I am not one of the Valar.
3. I am not one of the Maiar.
4. I was not alive during the War of the Ring.
5. I am an elf.
6. I am one of the Noldor.
7. I am not female.
2. I am not one of the Valar.
3. I am not one of the Maiar.
4. I was not alive during the War of the Ring.
5. I am an elf.
6. I am one of the Noldor.
7. I am not female.
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Mon Jan 02, 2023 3:42 am
Died you in the Dagorlad?
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Mon Jan 02, 2023 5:51 am
1. I am immortal.
2. I am not one of the Valar.
3. I am not one of the Maiar.
4. I was not alive during the War of the Ring.
5. I am an elf.
6. I am one of the Noldor.
7. I am not female.
8. I died in the Dagorlad.
2. I am not one of the Valar.
3. I am not one of the Maiar.
4. I was not alive during the War of the Ring.
5. I am an elf.
6. I am one of the Noldor.
7. I am not female.
8. I died in the Dagorlad.
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Tue Jan 03, 2023 7:17 pm
Hmm, are you an elven commander?
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Tue Jan 03, 2023 8:59 pm
1. I am immortal.
2. I am not one of the Valar.
3. I am not one of the Maiar.
4. I was not alive during the War of the Ring.
5. I am an elf.
6. I am one of the Noldor.
7. I am not female.
8. I died in the Dagorlad.
9. I am an elven commander.
2. I am not one of the Valar.
3. I am not one of the Maiar.
4. I was not alive during the War of the Ring.
5. I am an elf.
6. I am one of the Noldor.
7. I am not female.
8. I died in the Dagorlad.
9. I am an elven commander.
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Tue Jan 03, 2023 9:26 pm
Amdir Malgalad perhaps, the father of Amroth, king of Lorien?
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Tue Jan 03, 2023 9:50 pm
(this is the point at which I issue a 'mea culpa' and point out that I was mistaken on one point - credit it to having been out of Middle-earth for so long! 
)
8. I did NOT die in the Dagorlad.
)8. I did NOT die in the Dagorlad.
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Tue Jan 03, 2023 10:55 pm
Not dead? Ouch. There are not elven commanders dying in the third age. What then?
Hotshot Elrond, if you keep on living?
Hotshot Elrond, if you keep on living?
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Wed Jan 04, 2023 9:19 pm
A point of clarification I think is important here: in terms of Dagorlad, I'm referring specifically to the location. As in, the desolate plain outside the Ephel Duath. This person did not die in that location.Aikári Salmarinian wrote: ↑Tue Jan 03, 2023 10:55 pm Not dead? Ouch. There are not elven commanders dying in the third age. What then?
Hotshot Elrond, if you keep on living?
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Wed Jan 04, 2023 11:19 pm
Hmm, you're not Elrond then, I take it.
Did you survive into the Third Age?
Did you survive into the Third Age?
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Thu Jan 05, 2023 1:06 am
1. I am immortal.
2. I am not one of the Valar.
3. I am not one of the Maiar.
4. I was not alive during the War of the Ring.
5. I am an elf.
6. I am one of the Noldor.
7. I am not female.
8. I did not die in the Dagorlad.
9. I am an elven commander.
10. I did not survive to the Third Age.
2. I am not one of the Valar.
3. I am not one of the Maiar.
4. I was not alive during the War of the Ring.
5. I am an elf.
6. I am one of the Noldor.
7. I am not female.
8. I did not die in the Dagorlad.
9. I am an elven commander.
10. I did not survive to the Third Age.
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Thu Jan 05, 2023 7:29 am
Did you survive and live to see the Second Age?
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Thu Jan 05, 2023 5:41 pm
1. I am immortal.
2. I am not one of the Valar.
3. I am not one of the Maiar.
4. I was not alive during the War of the Ring.
5. I am an elf.
6. I am one of the Noldor.
7. I am not female.
8. I did not die in the Dagorlad.
9. I am an elven commander.
10. I did not survive to the Third Age.
11. I did live and survive to see the Second Age.
2. I am not one of the Valar.
3. I am not one of the Maiar.
4. I was not alive during the War of the Ring.
5. I am an elf.
6. I am one of the Noldor.
7. I am not female.
8. I did not die in the Dagorlad.
9. I am an elven commander.
10. I did not survive to the Third Age.
11. I did live and survive to see the Second Age.
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Thu Jan 05, 2023 11:28 pm
Are you family of Elrond?
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Fri Jan 06, 2023 12:42 am
1. I am immortal.
2. I am not one of the Valar.
3. I am not one of the Maiar.
4. I was not alive during the War of the Ring.
5. I am an elf.
6. I am one of the Noldor.
7. I am not female.
8. I did not die in the Dagorlad.
9. I am an elven commander.
10. I did not survive to the Third Age.
11. I did live and survive to see the Second Age.
12. I am (distantly) related to Elrond.
2. I am not one of the Valar.
3. I am not one of the Maiar.
4. I was not alive during the War of the Ring.
5. I am an elf.
6. I am one of the Noldor.
7. I am not female.
8. I did not die in the Dagorlad.
9. I am an elven commander.
10. I did not survive to the Third Age.
11. I did live and survive to see the Second Age.
12. I am (distantly) related to Elrond.
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Fri Jan 06, 2023 2:30 am
No idea I have yet, hmmm.
Are you maternally related?
Are you maternally related?
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Tue Jan 10, 2023 12:29 am
1. I am immortal.
2. I am not one of the Valar.
3. I am not one of the Maiar.
4. I was not alive during the War of the Ring.
5. I am an elf.
6. I am one of the Noldor.
7. I am not female.
8. I did not die in the Dagorlad.
9. I am an elven commander.
10. I did not survive to the Third Age.
11. I did live and survive to see the Second Age.
12. I am (distantly) related to Elrond.
13. I am maternally related to Elrond.
('maternally related' to mean that this person's most direct relation to Elrond is through his mother)
2. I am not one of the Valar.
3. I am not one of the Maiar.
4. I was not alive during the War of the Ring.
5. I am an elf.
6. I am one of the Noldor.
7. I am not female.
8. I did not die in the Dagorlad.
9. I am an elven commander.
10. I did not survive to the Third Age.
11. I did live and survive to see the Second Age.
12. I am (distantly) related to Elrond.
13. I am maternally related to Elrond.
('maternally related' to mean that this person's most direct relation to Elrond is through his mother)
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Wed Jan 11, 2023 10:31 pm
Are you Celebrimbor?
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Thu Jan 12, 2023 1:43 am
1. I am immortal.
2. I am not one of the Valar.
3. I am not one of the Maiar.
4. I was not alive during the War of the Ring.
5. I am an elf.
6. I am one of the Noldor.
7. I am not female.
8. I did not die in the Dagorlad.
9. I am an elven commander.
10. I did not survive to the Third Age.
11. I did live and survive to see the Second Age.
12. I am (distantly) related to Elrond.
13. I am maternally related to Elrond.
14. I am not Celebrimbor.
2. I am not one of the Valar.
3. I am not one of the Maiar.
4. I was not alive during the War of the Ring.
5. I am an elf.
6. I am one of the Noldor.
7. I am not female.
8. I did not die in the Dagorlad.
9. I am an elven commander.
10. I did not survive to the Third Age.
11. I did live and survive to see the Second Age.
12. I am (distantly) related to Elrond.
13. I am maternally related to Elrond.
14. I am not Celebrimbor.
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Sat Jan 14, 2023 1:03 am
Does your name begin with Fin?
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Sat Jan 14, 2023 1:11 am
1. I am immortal.
2. I am not one of the Valar.
3. I am not one of the Maiar.
4. I was not alive during the War of the Ring.
5. I am an elf.
6. I am one of the Noldor.
7. I am not female.
8. I did not die in the Dagorlad.
9. I am an elven commander.
10. I did not survive to the Third Age.
11. I did live and survive to see the Second Age.
12. I am (distantly) related to Elrond.
13. I am maternally related to Elrond.
14. I am not Celebrimbor.
15. My name does not begin with "Fin-"
2. I am not one of the Valar.
3. I am not one of the Maiar.
4. I was not alive during the War of the Ring.
5. I am an elf.
6. I am one of the Noldor.
7. I am not female.
8. I did not die in the Dagorlad.
9. I am an elven commander.
10. I did not survive to the Third Age.
11. I did live and survive to see the Second Age.
12. I am (distantly) related to Elrond.
13. I am maternally related to Elrond.
14. I am not Celebrimbor.
15. My name does not begin with "Fin-"
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Sat Jan 14, 2023 2:59 pm
Are you Galathil the brother of Celeborn?
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Sat Jan 14, 2023 3:10 pm
1. I am immortal.
2. I am not one of the Valar.
3. I am not one of the Maiar.
4. I was not alive during the War of the Ring.
5. I am an elf.
6. I am one of the Noldor.
7. I am not female.
8. I did not die in the Dagorlad.
9. I am an elven commander.
10. I did not survive to the Third Age.
11. I did live and survive to see the Second Age.
12. I am (distantly) related to Elrond.
13. I am maternally related to Elrond.
14. My name does not begin with "Fin-"
Incorrect Guesses: Celebrimbor, Galathil
2. I am not one of the Valar.
3. I am not one of the Maiar.
4. I was not alive during the War of the Ring.
5. I am an elf.
6. I am one of the Noldor.
7. I am not female.
8. I did not die in the Dagorlad.
9. I am an elven commander.
10. I did not survive to the Third Age.
11. I did live and survive to see the Second Age.
12. I am (distantly) related to Elrond.
13. I am maternally related to Elrond.
14. My name does not begin with "Fin-"
Incorrect Guesses: Celebrimbor, Galathil
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Sat Jan 14, 2023 7:24 pm
Are you Elmo perhaps?
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Sat Jan 14, 2023 9:30 pm
1. I am immortal.
2. I am not one of the Valar.
3. I am not one of the Maiar.
4. I was not alive during the War of the Ring.
5. I am an elf.
6. I am one of the Noldor.
7. I am not female.
8. I did not die in the Dagorlad.
9. I am an elven commander.
10. I did not survive to the Third Age.
11. I did live and survive to see the Second Age.
12. I am (distantly) related to Elrond.
13. I am maternally related to Elrond.
14. My name does not begin with "Fin-"
Incorrect Guesses: Celebrimbor, Galathil, Elmo
2. I am not one of the Valar.
3. I am not one of the Maiar.
4. I was not alive during the War of the Ring.
5. I am an elf.
6. I am one of the Noldor.
7. I am not female.
8. I did not die in the Dagorlad.
9. I am an elven commander.
10. I did not survive to the Third Age.
11. I did live and survive to see the Second Age.
12. I am (distantly) related to Elrond.
13. I am maternally related to Elrond.
14. My name does not begin with "Fin-"
Incorrect Guesses: Celebrimbor, Galathil, Elmo
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Sat Jan 14, 2023 10:14 pm
Are you Olwë?
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Sat Jan 14, 2023 11:13 pm
1. I am immortal.
2. I am not one of the Valar.
3. I am not one of the Maiar.
4. I was not alive during the War of the Ring.
5. I am an elf.
6. I am one of the Noldor.
7. I am not female.
8. I did not die in the Dagorlad.
9. I am an elven commander.
10. I did not survive to the Third Age.
11. I did live and survive to see the Second Age.
12. I am (distantly) related to Elrond.
13. I am maternally related to Elrond.
14. My name does not begin with "Fin-"
Incorrect Guesses: Celebrimbor, Galathil, Elmo, Olwë
2. I am not one of the Valar.
3. I am not one of the Maiar.
4. I was not alive during the War of the Ring.
5. I am an elf.
6. I am one of the Noldor.
7. I am not female.
8. I did not die in the Dagorlad.
9. I am an elven commander.
10. I did not survive to the Third Age.
11. I did live and survive to see the Second Age.
12. I am (distantly) related to Elrond.
13. I am maternally related to Elrond.
14. My name does not begin with "Fin-"
Incorrect Guesses: Celebrimbor, Galathil, Elmo, Olwë
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Sun Jan 15, 2023 12:37 pm
Are you Ingwë?
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Sun Jan 15, 2023 2:11 pm
1. I am immortal.
2. I am not one of the Valar.
3. I am not one of the Maiar.
4. I was not alive during the War of the Ring.
5. I am an elf.
6. I am one of the Noldor.
7. I am not female.
8. I did not die in the Dagorlad.
9. I am an elven commander.
10. I did not survive to the Third Age.
11. I did live and survive to see the Second Age.
12. I am (distantly) related to Elrond.
13. I am maternally related to Elrond.
14. My name does not begin with "Fin-"
Incorrect Guesses: Celebrimbor, Galathil, Elmo, Olwë, Ingwë
2. I am not one of the Valar.
3. I am not one of the Maiar.
4. I was not alive during the War of the Ring.
5. I am an elf.
6. I am one of the Noldor.
7. I am not female.
8. I did not die in the Dagorlad.
9. I am an elven commander.
10. I did not survive to the Third Age.
11. I did live and survive to see the Second Age.
12. I am (distantly) related to Elrond.
13. I am maternally related to Elrond.
14. My name does not begin with "Fin-"
Incorrect Guesses: Celebrimbor, Galathil, Elmo, Olwë, Ingwë
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Mon Jan 16, 2023 9:33 am
Are you also paternally related?
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Mon Jan 23, 2023 11:19 am
@Reikon Suchi-ru - Are you Gil-galad, the last High King of the Noldor?
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Tue Jan 24, 2023 1:43 pm
Yes! I am Gil-galad. Well done, @Drifa. 
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Tue Jan 24, 2023 11:12 pm
Reikon: Eh... You said not to die in the Dagorlad under question 8, but that is what Gil did. He did not survive that battle.
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Wed Jan 25, 2023 10:49 am
Reik clarified this, Aiks.Reikon Suchi-ru wrote: ↑Wed Jan 04, 2023 9:19 pmA point of clarification I think is important here: in terms of Dagorlad, I'm referring specifically to the location. As in, the desolate plain outside the Ephel Duath. This person did not die in that location.Aikári Salmarinian wrote: ↑Tue Jan 03, 2023 10:55 pm Not dead? Ouch. There are not elven commanders dying in the third age. What then?
Hotshot Elrond, if you keep on living?
Where am I?
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Wed Jan 25, 2023 3:45 pm
I had to do some digging on the Battle of Dagorlad situation, hence the clarification. Gil-galad died during the Siege of Barad-dur, which immediately followed the Battle of Dagorlad and lasted at least 7 years. But depending on your interpretation, the Battle of Dagorlad and the Siege of Barad-dur can be seen as the same conflict, or they can be viewed separately. Adopting a more narrow view of Dagorlad as location and not specifically the Battle of Dagorlad allowed for more specificity, since we know for certain that Gil-galad did not die in the location. It was a tricky question to answer, I wish I had had a better way to answer so as not to mislead, I apologize!
Re: Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?
Posted: Wed Jan 25, 2023 6:42 pm
The Dagorlad is an event to me, not particular the location, but is alright Reikon, it was fun guessing. 
Drifa: Good luck! And the first question: Are you a dwarf?
Drifa: Good luck! And the first question: Are you a dwarf?